Browse more stays in Cottekill, NY

Renovated Farmhouse

4 BR · 3 BA · sleeps 8 · house

★ 4.97228 verified reviews
Photo 1 of 7 of Renovated Farmhouse
Photo 2 of 7 of Renovated FarmhousePhoto 3 of 7 of Renovated FarmhousePhoto 4 of 7 of Renovated FarmhousePhoto 5 of 7 of Renovated FarmhousePhoto 6 of 7 of Renovated FarmhousePhoto 7 of 7 of Renovated Farmhouse

About this property

Morning in Cottekill starts in a rocking chair on the wraparound porch, coffee in hand, looking out over a fenced lawn and big old trees. The O&W Rail Trail begins just across the road, so a shaded walk in the woods is only a few steps away.

Inside, the 1870s farmhouse is all tall windows and soft light, with four bedrooms and three full baths for up to eight. The open chef's kitchen has a huge island where someone can always keep the cook company, and the long wooden dining table invites slow dinners and board games. Evenings drift to the living room, where the wood-burning fireplace crackles.

Out back, two acres of grass and trees open up, with a hammock strung for lazy afternoons. After dark, the fire pit is ready for s'mores, and the outdoor hot tub steams in every season. In the barn, a ping pong table, a dartboard and a pair of mountain bikes wait for a rematch.

Stone Ridge is about five minutes away for dinner and groceries, and New Paltz and Kingston are each roughly fifteen. Mohonk Preserve and Minnewaska make easy hiking days. On the way back, a pizza from Ollie's, less than five minutes from the door, closes out a long day outdoors.

What guests keep mentioning

Themes that recur across 228 public reviews. Paraphrased, never quoted.

  • O&W Rail Trail at the door
  • Well-stocked chef's kitchen
  • Porch with rocking chairs
  • Wood-burning fireplace
  • Outdoor hot tub