Castle by the Lake

About this property

Castle by the Lake sits on a private lot in Lake Peekskill, built into a rocky hillside with the look of a small stone fortress. Guests describe gargoyles, stained glass, and reclaimed oak floors that make the interior feel unlike a standard rental. The theme guests raise most is the host's responsiveness, with many calling her quick to answer questions and present for check in when needed. The second most mentioned theme is the building itself, guests keep finding new details around every corner and call the exterior and grounds striking.

Outdoor space comes up often too. Reviewers describe multiple tiered decks and seating areas, a fire pit with room for a group, and grounds well suited to gathering rather than just passing through. Several groups used the space for themed weekends, from game nights to birthday parties, and found the layout worked for spreading out without feeling cramped even with ten or more people.

The kitchen earns steady praise for being well equipped, letting groups cook full meals rather than rely on takeout. A few reviewers mention that beds and linens were more comfortable than expected for an older home. Some guests note the house runs warm in summer heat and that the age of the building shows in occasional musty smells or ceiling water stains, worth knowing before booking in peak summer.

With four bedrooms and space for up to 14, the home suits groups looking for a shared base with personality rather than a standard house. Lake access and hiking trails sit nearby, and guests mention using the property as a home base for exploring the wider Hudson Valley.